Educators save $200,000 with OSGrid

A group of educators has come together to create an enclave on OSGrid, a non-profit grid running on the OpenSim software — and, in so doing, saved themselves around $200,000 compared to what they would have paid for the same land in Second Life.

John Rogate

The project, the OSGrid Educational Cooperative, is led by John Rogate, the director of the Master’s in Managing Innovation & Information Technology program at Vermont’s Champlain College, and began a month ago with an open letter by written by Rogate. It currently covers 56 regions for a total land area of 896 acres or 3.6 million square meters.

“It is good to see a plan come together,” Rogate told Hypergrid Business.

Most educational institutions involved in the project are running their own servers, though Rogate says he’s hosting three schools until they are able to get OpenSim servers approved by their IT departments.

CampChamp1 is one of several Champlain College regions on OSGrid.

Rogate said that he is using his own regions to hold classes, and as a virtual showcase.

“If I could get money for one more server, I can do another 10 to 20 regions,” he added.

And that might happen, he said. “I think I will have a phase II of the project with more educators.”

Today, the project spans 56 regions on OSGrid, the largest grid running on the OpenSim software. It includes several regions reserved for Champlain College, and three public sandboxes. Other participants include Ohio’s Columbus State Community College, Iowa’s Clinton, Muscatine and Scott Community Colleges, George Mason University, University of East London, Anglia Ruskin University, and the Virtual Native Lands project.

Several universities from the Netherlands are also participating, including Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Universiteit Utrecht, Maastricht University, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, Delft University of Technology, University of GroningenTilburg University, University of Twente, Leiden University, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen,  Wageningen University, and the Eindhoven University of Technology.

OSGrid's mkholland4 region.

According to Rogate, the same 56 regions, at the standard Linden Lab rate of $295 a month, would have cost more than $198,000 a year on Second Life.

And he wasn’t counting the $56,000 in setup fees to get the new regions up and running.

By having the colleges group together, they can do more than reduce their land costs to close to zero — they can share other resources, as well.

“Everyone doesn’t have to have a sandbox, or a theater, or a freebee store,” said Rogate. “They can be centralized on the grid.”

Training in how to use the virtual environment can also be a joint effort, he added.

“OSGrid is based on sharing resources and keeping costs in line,” confirmed Glenn Williams, Information Technology Instructor at Clinton Community College. “In this project, we have several colleges working together to create an area to share and learn together.”

The Clinton Community College currently has a single region in Second Life, but will not be renewing it when the contract expires, said Williams, also known as “Glenn Tigerpaw” in-world.

Glenn Williams

“The Lindens are taking away the educational pricing, we cannot continue to pay for the area,” said Williams, referring to the end of the educational discount at the start of this year.

“OSGrid allows us to build a virtual world at no cost,” he said. “We maintain our own servers and really set our own rules.”

The college will use its land on OSGrid to allow students to work on projects in virtual design, architecture, and programming.

“I would like the art students to work on 3D modeling, and the networking students to build a virtual network,” he said.

The land will also be used to hold distance learning classes, he added.

“It is not as smooth as Second Life, but I have a feeling that will change as they work the bugs out of the software,” he said. “Second Life is more established and there are a lot more things available.”

But the cost savings more than make up for it, he added. In Second Life, the college was spending around $3,000 a year for a single region — and now has 10 regions at no cost. “You do the math,” he said.

The move isn’t easy, he added.

“Transferring content from Second Life to OpenSim is a problem,” he said. “A lot of items cannot be transferred and even with the Second Inventory program, not everything will move over correctly.”

Glenn Willaims' avatar on the Clinton-IT region on OSGrid, starting with a clean slate.

Under Linden rules, objects can only be exported by their original creators — and if an object has parts created by others, it cannot be exported at all, even if those parts were distributed under a Creative Commons license. Many objects, for example, use free third-party textures or other components.

This is a particular problem for education institutions, where a number of educators and students often work together to create a single build.

But once the move is made, OpenSim makes it easy to export full regions, or entire avatar inventories, said Rogate.

This means that educators can save backup copies of their builds, or archive early versions of their builds. Educators can also share full regions with one another. Free region files — in the form of OAR exports — are available to download from OpenSim Creations and OpenSim Worlds.

OSGrid advantages

By hosting regions on OSGrid, instead of running a private grid, or going off into separate mini-grids, the colleges can leave a lot of work to OSGrid’s administrators. For example, OSGrid handles all the avatar inventories, and organizes the region locations on the map. OSGrid is also home to many freebie stores, training classes, networking events, and has the largest community of users in OpenSim.

As a non-profit, OSGrid is also committed to keeping the grid from becoming too commercial, which also fits in well with educational objects.

And OSGrid is hypergrid-enabled, meaning that educators and students can visit other grids — like the German-language GermanGrid, or the French-language FrancoGrid, or other educational grids like Jokaydia Grid and ReactionGrid.

But educators don’t have to be part of the official OSGrid Educational Cooperative in order to get many of the same benefits.

Williams said that he’s willing to network with other educators on OSGrid, including those not part of this educational enclave.

“The more people move to OSGrid, the better it can be,” he said.

For example, Barbara Janson, chief librarian at Rhode Island’s Johnson & Wales University, used a hosting company, Nova, to get a region on OSGrid for less than $10 a month.

“I rented a small island from Nova,” she said. “They were wonderful.”

Lifelong Learning Library, Janson's new region on OSGrid.

Nova, formerly New Voice, is a popular hosting vendor for low-cost, low-traffic regions on OSGrid, though they also have high-demand regions available for $90 a month.

OSGrid, as a non-profit, does not rent regions itself. People can connect regions that they run on their home computers — or on their school servers — at no cost. Or they can use a third-party hosting company like Nova, Oliveira, or Dreamland Metaverse.

A full list of hosting providers is here. Any of those in the left-hand “Multi Grid” column can host regions attached to OSGrid.

Those with the technical skills to install and run an OpenSim server software, open the firewall, and route the necessary ports, can download a version of OpenSim optimized for use on OSGrid here on their download page. If you need help, OSGrid has its own IRC chat channel, which is one of the busiest discussion forums for OpenSim. Additional help is available through the OSGrid Forums, or in (virtual) person on OSGrid’s welcome area, the always-busy LBSA Plaza region.

Read more about getting started in OpenSim here.

maria@hypergridbusiness.com'

Maria Korolov

Maria Korolov is editor and publisher of Hypergrid Business. She has been a journalist for more than twenty years and has worked for the Chicago Tribune, Reuters, and Computerworld and has reported from over a dozen countries, including Russia and China.

  • Upate from Rogate:

    There will be a freebie center and welcome and information area on region "mkholland4"
    "ChamplanColl07" region will be a common meeting facility, a theater, and a nursery with hundreds of plant varieties.

    The group is also thinking of expanding the project to include a few other schools, and to have a 100 regions altogether on OSGrid.

  • Graham Mills

    If you will forgive the flag-waving, I would just add that the non-profit New World Grid is also strongly oriented towards culture and education builds. Furthermore, as you know, it will not be possible to jump to other edu grids until they are on the same Hypergrid version. Hopefully that will not be too long. While there have been universities on OSGrid for some time, my understanding was that it tends to run bleeding edge code. While that may be beneficial in terms of having access to the latest feature set, it presumably comes with some risks attached as well? Please correct me if I am wrong. Anyway, I wish John and his colleagues all the best and look forward to joining them via the Hypergrid in the not-too-distant future.

    • Ah I just saw this Peter…..Thanks for your support.
      Hey, we are all to be pioneers in this endeavor. Bleeding edge is for Pioneers. OSGrid is the haven of the OpenSim Developers. If there is an issue, they will fix it…and we also serve to test the new features in mass. So far so good. Being way behind in the update curve in this arena is not recommended. We need to move forward. I have over 37 years experience in the IS/IT arena. Though I am not the "controller" of this project…I will be the guide…and hopefully will keep folks out of any trouble.

      This is ALPHA software! One has to keep moving…. IN the techie world….logic will get us from point A to Point B. In the creative world, imagination will get us anywhere….

      I agree WE love New World Grid and have a presence there…but took it down until we can move to 7.1.1 and beyond.

  • How do you teach classes without voice? At Drexel University, we have a presence in OSGrid, but are limitied in what we can do with it due to the lack of voice.

  • Justin —

    My recommendation is to use Whisper/Mumble. It sounds as good as Vivox in SL. The only problem is that you have to have a special voice file for your viewer, which could be an obstacle for some users. If you have a viewer that you recommend to your students, simply add that file to the viewer, and distribute it as a package.

    If you want to do it yourself, instructions are here: http://whisper.vcomm.ch/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&a

    If you want to use a vendor, Dreamland Metaverse has been in the forefront of getting this to work.

    One of the next releases of Imprudence should have built in automatic switching between Whisper and Vivox, which will make deployment a lot easier.

    — Maria